Asheville Daily Planet
RSS Facebook
With ëDead Silence,í filmmakers reach new pinnacle of absurdity
Tuesday, 27 March 2007 14:14
By BLAISE FAY

I didnít think it was possible, but the creators of the ìSawî series have outdone themselves with their latest horror film, ìDead Silence.î

I would go so far as to call it the worst film Iíve ever seen of its genre ó possibly the worst film Iíve ever seen, period.


The film starts out when young couple Jamie (Ryan Kwanten) and Lisa Ashen (Laura Regan) find a mysterious package outside their door containing a creepy-looking ventriloquist dummy.


Instead of trashing or burning the hideous doll that we later find out is an omen (which they already knew), the couple play with the doll and then separate, leaving Lisa alone in a dark house, where appliances start acting funny and the house falls, well, dead silent.

After the dummy kills his wife (so predictably it hurts), Jamie Ashen is determined to find out the real cause of her death, so he travels back to their hometown, Ravenís Fair, a town with a population of about four people total.

The landscape of Ravenís Fair looks like Disneylandís version of a modern-day ghost town, painfully tacky and overdone. It doesnít give off a realistic sense of a rundown town at all. Instead, it screams: ill-conceived movie set.


And thatís not even the worst of it. Ashen is trailed by detective Jim Lipton (Donnie Wahlberg) who gives the lamest impression of a wise-cracking cop in the history of cinema and brandishes his asinine electric razor prop in almost every scene of the film.


I donít think Iíll ever get over the scene when Lipton chases Ashen, whining, ìI donít have a full tank of gas!î


Once the story movies to Ravenís Fair, logic has no place in this film. Ashen and Lipton fight over ìBillyî the doll and meanwhile uncover the story of ventriloquist Mary Shaw, who killed a boy who taunted her from the crowd.


Even the most simple-minded person would leave this film with all types of unanswered questions, but I think ìDead Silenceî has proven a very good point about a lot of todayís movie makers ó the better they get at making previews, the worse they get at making the actual movie.


I wonít go so far as to expose the shockingly stupid twist ending, but letís just say ìSawî fans will feel duped and possibly frightened... at how such an uninspired and absurd story made it to theaters.

There is nothing good about this film ó the acting is misdirected, thereís no character development whatsoever, the camera transitions are cheesy, ìShawî and ìdollsî donít rhyme and itís just not scary.
As for the whole ventriloquism idea, yeah, itís a good idea, but in ìDead Silenceî it doesnít work, and ìMagicî did it better.


So please, donít see this film. Itís not just about dummies, it was also made by them.

ï
Blaise Fay works for the Daily Planet.
 



 


contact | home

Copyright ©2005-2015 Star Fleet Communications

224 Broadway St., Asheville, NC 28801 | P.O. Box 8490, Asheville, NC 28814
phone (828) 252-6565 | fax (828) 252-6567

a Cube Creative Design site