Asheville Daily Planet
RSS Facebook
Opinion: Wrestling with questions, or resting in answers?
Tuesday, 09 January 2007 15:58
Marc Mullinax
"A clash of doctrines is not a disaster ÇƒÓ it is an opportunity."
 ÇƒÏ A.N. Whitehead
ï
MARS HILL ÇƒÓ "Who are you, to write such critical essays about our most sacred doctrines?" "Why do you keep on tearing down the faith?" "Do your views reflect the views of the college where you serve as chairman of the Philosophy and Religion Department?"

It appears Page 21 of this paper has become a lively place for many readers. Thank you. But critics seek answers again. Once more, let me explore why this religion professor from a Baptist college engages the topics that I do.

First, a story. In my last graduate school, there was a world-famous African-American liberation theologian, who was my professor the very first semester I attended. It was a course in liberation theology, comprising of about 15-20 students of all colors, sexual orientations and ages. White people were in the minority. Remember this.

The professor began to explain the texts for the day, demonstrating how voices from the underside of history have important theological points to make about God, Jesus and the Church. Such points are often neglected by mainstream Christianity. Some of the young white men began to discount these minority views as valid.


One even went so far as to question the validity of one of the professorës key ÇƒÓ and famous ¨?ÇƒÓ points: traditionally oppressed people, who have been systematically excluded from economic and social benefits are to be held in special regard. In other words, whatever personal or original sin they may be involved in is secondary to their victimization by social and economic conditions.


The professor went livid. He tiraded for about 10 minutes. Hereës a sampling of his argument. "I donët trust ... ANY of you white people! White supremacy has been the number one terror and threat to black people, and you still use your supremacist ways to deny your responsibility, short-change your constituency, and subvert democracy.


"Listen. Itës worse. You call yourself ǃÚChristianë. I donët think so. Because you are white, you can immunize yourself from racism and the unique suffering that comes from being the wrong color. And thus, because you donët suffer, youëll never, and I mean never EVER ǃÚgetë Christianity. Your interpretations of the Bible will always suffer from the neglect of black experience.


"Thatës the power of your racism. And it will keep you from being the Christian you think you are. Your whiteness means youëll never be black. And youëve got to be black ÇƒÏ in America today ÇƒÏ in order to understand Jesus and his religion."


I was blown away. The power of that moment remains undiminished to this day. Rarely do I open the Bible and not think about this story, and I vow that on this opening of the Bible, I can prove him wrong. My success has been less than noteworthy.


This professor asked for me the main question in my life, and I end with it by posing it here. If faith is too easy, is it not more habit, than real, struggling faith? Am I a Christian through force of habit and custom, or because of a real wrestling with the questions of life?


Answers I do not discount. We must have a blessed assurance about lifeës troubling issues.

Otherwise, we could not get out of bed and face the day. Nevertheless, it seems incumbent upon the person of faith to suspend their non-negotiables on a regular basis, become disoriented, and then discover what compass-like questions remain strong enough as a guide.


Therefore, dear readers, I wrestle and ask you here to wrestle with me hard questions, rather than rest in answers. This struggle, at least for me, has made all the difference. Such struggle makes faith much more difficult, and therefore more possible.

ï
Dr. Marc S. Mullinax, chairman of the philosophy and religion departments at Mars Hill College, can be reached at mmullinax-at-mhc.edu.

 



 


contact | home

Copyright ©2005-2015 Star Fleet Communications

224 Broadway St., Asheville, NC 28801 | P.O. Box 8490, Asheville, NC 28814
phone (828) 252-6565 | fax (828) 252-6567

a Cube Creative Design site