Asheville Daily Planet
RSS Facebook
Election reform might require a constitutional amendment
Wednesday, 02 August 2006 03:11

Bill Walz
Right-wing Republicans, when faced with Constitutional obstacles to their culture-war issues like gay marriage, immigration, abortion or flag desecration, never hesitate to seek to amend the Constitution.
They can be counted on, particularly around elections, to attempt to slip limits to liberty into this document that is meant to protect our liberties.

There is, however, one issue that seriously threatens liberty yet gets constitutional protection. All attempts to address the corrupting effect of corporations and special-interest groups spending vast sums of money to influence our legislative and election process seem to stumble on the steps of the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court has consistently ruled that money equates to constitutionally protected free speech and so all attempts to take special interest money out of politics have tripped on this barrier. I??m of the opinion that buying elections wasn??t what the founding fathers had in mind with the First Amendment, but that hasn??t been the way the Court has seen it. No, the protection that was meant to preserve the right of ordinary citizens to have their say in the Boston Commons, the town hall or little independent publications, is now interpreted so as to allow big-moneyed interests and corporations to dominate election and political issue speech.  

Of course, anyone in America can say whatever they like, with a very few reasonable limits. It??s still a free country. Or is it? The speech that becomes part of the public consciousness, and so decides political issues, is not free. It is effectively monopolized through money. Moneyed interests overwhelm the public with diversionary and inflammatory political propaganda ads. Through television, radio and publishing conglomerates, corporate agendas effectively control which positions are presented to the public and which are ignored, which are given solemn endorsement and which are ridiculed. Real debate about many very important issues never makes it through this supercilious, inflammatory and purposefully obfuscating prattle.


With the federal courts stacked with Republican judges, there is little chance of America reclaiming an independent and equal forum for election speech through the judiciary any time soon. No, to get such reform, the American public must push this issue. The people will have to insist that when the founders?? constitutional intentions are being undermined by technologies and economics that the founders could not have anticipated, then it is the people??s will to amend the Constitution. They will have to insist on putting to rest once and for all the corruption brought by those who believe America belongs to those with the money to buy it.


The amendment process was included in the Constitution to evolve freedoms and protections as unforeseen forces reshaped society and sometimes threatened liberty. As the founders had a deep suspicion of corporations, invented by the British to exploit their colonies, I believe that Jefferson and Franklin would see today??s near total corporate control of our society and the domination of political speech by corporate and moneyed interests, to be just such a threat.


Truly free elections require total public financing. Intelligent voting requires neutral and thorough news coverage of elections and public issues by the media. If the courts say there are constitutional barriers to these propositions, then these are issues worthy of debate towards amending the Constitution.

When truth and honest debate are drowned out by a cacophony of deceptions and diversionary prattle paid for by moneyed interest groups, then this clearly is not the democracy intended by our founders. Our free society, elections, press and speech have been bought and ?®we, the people,?∆ are paying the price.
?ÿ
Bill Walz is a UNC Asheville adjunct faculty member and a private-practice teacher of mindfulness, personal growth, and consciousness. Contact at bill.walz-at-worldnet.att.
 



 


contact | home

Copyright ©2005-2015 Star Fleet Communications

224 Broadway St., Asheville, NC 28801 | P.O. Box 8490, Asheville, NC 28814
phone (828) 252-6565 | fax (828) 252-6567

a Cube Creative Design site